Skip to content

South Yorkshire Police — Inspection History

Published HMICFRS inspection reports for South Yorkshire Police: grades, key findings and recommendations over time.

Back to South Yorkshire Police

His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) independently inspects police forces in England and Wales. This page collects the published inspection reports we have indexed for South Yorkshire Police — for the latest PEEL assessment snapshot, see the current HMICFRS rating.

PEEL 2023–2025: An inspection of South Yorkshire Police

2025-07-24 · peel report

This report sets out the findings for South Yorkshire Police under the PEEL framework, which assesses police effectiveness, efficiency, and legitimacy. The report concludes that South Yorkshire Police is good at preventing crime but must improve its investigations.

preventing crime: goodinvestigations: requires improvement
Key findings (8)
  • South Yorkshire Police is effective in preventing crime.
  • The force needs to enhance its investigation processes.
  • Community engagement has shown positive outcomes.
  • Resource allocation requires further optimization.
  • Training programs for officers need updating.
  • Data analysis capabilities improve operational focus.
  • Public satisfaction remains a priority area.
  • Partnerships with local agencies enhance service delivery.
Recommendations (8)
  • Increase focus on improving investigation quality.
  • Enhance training programs for investigative officers.
  • Allocate more resources to high-impact areas.
  • Strengthen community engagement initiatives.
  • Develop a strategy for better data utilization.
  • Establish clearer metrics for success in investigations.
  • Foster collaboration across law enforcement agencies.
  • Engage more with public feedback mechanisms.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

A report into the effectiveness of vetting arrangements in South Yorkshire Police

2023-09-21 · peel report

In April 2023, HMICFRS inspected South Yorkshire Police to examine the effectiveness of the force’s vetting arrangements. The report outlines the findings regarding the management and effectiveness of vetting in the police force.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL 2021/22 – An inspection of South Yorkshire Police

2023-02-02 · peel report

This report sets out the findings for South Yorkshire Police as part of HMICFRS’s assessment of police forces in England and Wales. The assessment covers effectiveness, efficiency, and legitimacy, evaluating the overall performance of the force.

Effectiveness: GoodEfficiency: GoodLegitimacy: Good
Key findings (4)
  • South Yorkshire Police has been praised for its strong performance.
  • The force has made significant improvements in areas of effectiveness.
  • Efficiency measures have been effectively implemented, leading to better resource management.
  • Legitimacy in policing has been rated positively, with good practices in community engagement.
Recommendations (3)
  • Continue to build on the effectiveness strategies to maintain high performance levels.
  • Enhance collaboration with community stakeholders for improved legitimacy.
  • Focus on sustained efficiency improvements to address future challenges.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Police – Joint inspection of police custody

2019-10-01 · thematic report

This inspection into South Yorkshire Police is one of a series on police custody inspections carried out jointly by HMI Prisons and HMICFRS. The programme looks at strategy, treatment and conditions, individual rights and health care. It also contributes to the UK’s response to its international obligation to ensure regular and independent inspection of all places of detention.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: Police effectiveness, efficiency and legitimacy 2018/19 – South Yorkshire Police

2019-09-27 · peel report

PEEL is HMICFRS’s annual assessment of police forces in England and Wales, focusing on their effectiveness, efficiency, and legitimacy. This report for South Yorkshire Police discusses their performance for the year 2018/19, highlighting an integrated approach to inspections that combines these areas into a single evaluation.

Effectiveness: GoodEfficiency: GoodLegitimacy: Good
Key findings (8)
  • South Yorkshire Police was assessed as 'Good' in effectiveness, efficiency, and legitimacy.
  • The integrated approach allowed for a more comprehensive assessment than previous years.
  • Key areas for improvement were identified alongside notable practices.
  • Community engagement has shown positive results in crime reduction.
  • Management of workloads has improved, contributing to better outcomes.
  • There are strong partnerships in place with local agencies to enhance safety.
  • Ongoing training is essential for staff to adapt to new challenges.
  • Public confidence in the police has seen a gradual increase.
Recommendations (8)
  • Continue to improve community engagement for better trust and transparency.
  • Address identified areas for improvement from the assessment to maintain standards.
  • Enhance training programs for officers to keep pace with evolving challenges.
  • Strengthen partnerships with local agencies for more effective crime prevention.
  • Regularly review workload management to sustain effectiveness.
  • Monitor public perception and adjust strategies to maintain confidence.
  • Invest in technology to support operational efficiency.
  • Ensure ongoing assessment to adapt to changing community needs.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police effectiveness 2017 – South Yorkshire Police

2018-03-22 · peel report

This report assesses how effective South Yorkshire Police is at keeping people safe and reducing crime. It evaluates five key areas of policing efficiency and effectiveness as part of the PEEL assessment. The findings follow previous reports on efficiency and legitimacy, completing the annual review of the force.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police legitimacy 2017 - South Yorkshire Police

2017-12-12 · peel report

This inspection looked at how the South Yorkshire Police treats people with fairness and respect, ensuring an ethical and lawful workforce that also feels respected. The report outlines the findings specific to South Yorkshire Police and supports national themes in legitimacy assessments.

Overall Legitimacy: Good
Key findings (8)
  • The inspection assesses how well South Yorkshire Police treats people fairly and with respect.
  • It evaluates the conduct of the police workforce regarding ethics and legality.
  • The report draws comparisons with the national overview and previous reports.
  • It highlights the ongoing efforts of the police to enhance their legitimacy.
  • The findings reflect public perception and workforce morale in the police force.
  • Future reports on effectiveness are forthcoming, building on this legitimacy assessment.
  • It identifies persistent concerns regarding stop and search disparities.
  • It seeks to promote trust between the police and the community.
Recommendations (8)
  • Enhance training on fairness and respect within the force.
  • Develop strategies to improve community engagement.
  • Address disparities in stop and search practices.
  • Continuous assessment of workforce morale and ethical conduct.
  • Implement more transparent reporting of policing practices.
  • Strengthen community feedback mechanisms.
  • Regular training sessions focused on ethics for new recruits.
  • Collaboration with community organizations to build trust.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police efficiency 2017 - South Yorkshire Police

2017-11-09 · peel report

This inspection examined how well South Yorkshire Police understand the demand for their service, how well they match their resources to that demand, and how well they are planning to meet future demand. The report provides an assessment of their efficiency.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Abuse of position assessment - South Yorkshire Police

2017-10-05 · peel report

In our 2016 legitimacy inspections, a national cause of concern was identified in forces’ ability to seek intelligence on potential abuse of position for sexual gain. HMICFRS recommended that all forces should have implemented a plan to achieve the capacity required to seek such intelligence. A review in 2017 assessed the plans provided by forces, including South Yorkshire Police's response to these recommendations.

Legitimacy: requires improvement
Key findings (3)
  • Concern over the ability to seek intelligence on abuse of position for sexual gain.
  • Recommendation for forces to implement plans to address this issue.
  • Assessment of individual plans was communicated to the chief constable of South Yorkshire Police.
Recommendations (2)
  • South Yorkshire Police should enhance their capability to seek intelligence on abuse of position for sexual gain.
  • All forces should review their progress and report on the effectiveness of their plans.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police effectiveness 2016 – South Yorkshire Police

2017-03-02 · peel report

This report assesses how effective South Yorkshire Police is at keeping people safe and reducing crime, focusing on five key areas of policing effectiveness. The assessment follows other reports on efficiency and legitimacy, completing the annual PEEL inspection framework.

Overall Effectiveness: Good
Key findings (5)
  • The force is effective at preventing crime.
  • The force has improved its approach to tackling anti-social behaviour.
  • Investigation processes have seen significant enhancement.
  • Support for vulnerable individuals is robust.
  • The force demonstrates strong capabilities in tackling serious and organised crime.
Recommendations (5)
  • Enhance community engagement strategies.
  • Increase training for investigators on complex cases.
  • Improve technology integration in crime investigations.
  • Strengthen the relationship between police and local communities.
  • Regularly assess the effectiveness of prevention strategies.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Best Use of Stop and Search revisit – South Yorkshire Police

2017-02-02 · thematic report

This revisit inspection assessed South Yorkshire Police's compliance with the Best Use of Stop and Search scheme. The findings indicated the need for improvements in several key areas for better adherence to the scheme's requirements.

Compliance with the Best Use of Stop and Search scheme: requires improvement
Key findings (8)
  • South Yorkshire Police was not complying with several features of the BUSS scheme.
  • In 2015, only 11 of 43 forces complied with all features of the scheme.
  • 19 forces, including South Yorkshire, were non-compliant in one or two areas.
  • The revisit aimed to evaluate steps taken to improve compliance.
  • The BUSS scheme aims for increased community involvement and transparency.
  • The 2015 PEEL inspection highlighted significant non-compliance issues.
  • The scheme addresses monitoring the impact of stop and search on communities.
  • There was a need for effective data recording and community outreach.
Recommendations (8)
  • South Yorkshire Police should enhance training on stop and search procedures.
  • Implement stronger monitoring systems for stop and search outcomes.
  • Increase community engagement initiatives related to stop and search.
  • Regularly review and publish compliance data for transparency.
  • Establish clear communication channels for community complaints.
  • Improve support for officers in applying stop and search policies.
  • Promote accountability within the force for compliance.
  • Collaborate with local communities to rebuild trust.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police legitimacy 2016 - South Yorkshire Police

2016-12-08 · peel report

The PEEL report assessed South Yorkshire Police's treatment of people with respect and fairness, alongside the ethical conduct of their workforce. It aims to highlight overarching themes related to legitimacy in policing.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

PEEL: police efficiency 2016 - South Yorkshire Police

2016-11-03 · peel report

This inspection assessed how well each force in England and Wales understands the demand for its service and how well it matches its resources to that demand, specifically for South Yorkshire Police. Key findings include the efficacy of resource allocation and the understanding of service demand.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Rape Monitoring Group digest - 2015/16

2016-10-13 · thematic report

This digest provides a data set for the national Rape Monitoring Group, outlining how rape is addressed in South Yorkshire. It compiles data from various official sources to enhance understanding and analysis of rape cases in the area.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Section 38 - South Yorkshire Police

2016-09-29 · national report

This publication covers the High Court judgment regarding the judicial review brought by former South Yorkshire Chief Constable David Crompton, which quashed the police and crime commissioner's decision to force his resignation following the Hillsborough inquests verdict. The Chief Inspector of Constabulary supported Crompton in the litigation.

Key findings (3)
  • The High Court ruled that the police and crime commissioner's decisions were quashed.
  • HMCIC supported Chief Constable David Crompton in the judicial proceedings.
  • This judgment addresses accountability in the wake of the Hillsborough inquests.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Police effectiveness 2015 – South Yorkshire Police

2016-02-18 · peel report

As part of its annual inspections into police effectiveness, efficiency and legitimacy (PEEL), HMIC’s effectiveness programme assessed how effective the force is at keeping people safe and reducing crime and anti-social behaviour. This inspection focused on four aspects of policing: preventing crime and anti-social behaviour; investigating crime and managing offenders; protecting vulnerable people and supporting victims; and tackling serious and organised crime.

Preventing crime and anti-social behaviour: GoodInvestigating crime and managing offenders: Requires ImprovementProtecting vulnerable people and supporting victims: GoodTackling serious and organised crime: Requires Improvement
Key findings (4)
  • The South Yorkshire Police is generally good at preventing crime and anti-social behaviour.
  • There are issues with the quality of investigations within the force.
  • The force is effective in supporting victims, particularly vulnerable individuals.
  • Coordination against serious and organised crime needs improvement.
Recommendations (3)
  • Enhance methodologies for investigating crime for better outcomes.
  • Increase efforts in training officers on dealing with serious and organised crime.
  • Implement a structured review process for anti-social behaviour cases.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Police legitimacy 2015 – South Yorkshire Police

2016-02-11 · peel report

The HMIC assessed the legitimacy of South Yorkshire Police as part of its PEEL inspections, focusing on how fairly and effectively the force operates in keeping the public safe and reducing crime. The report evaluates the force's consistency in fair behavior and public trust.

Legitimacy: requires improvement
Key findings (3)
  • South Yorkshire Police was deemed to have failed in one or more areas of the Best Use of Stop and Search Scheme during the 2015 inspection.
  • The force was assessed on how it maintains public trust and safety when performing its duties.
  • The inspection included examining the force's adherence to rules concerning stop and search practices.
Recommendations (3)
  • Improvement is needed in compliance with the Best Use of Stop and Search Scheme.
  • The force should focus on enhancing public engagement to maintain trust.
  • Continuous training for officers on fair policing practices is recommended.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Police effectiveness 2015 (Vulnerability) – South Yorkshire Police

2015-12-15 · peel report

This report assesses how well South Yorkshire Police protects those who are vulnerable and supports victims. It focuses on the response to and support for missing and absent children and victims of domestic abuse, highlighting how prepared the force is to safeguard children at risk of sexual exploitation.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

Witness for the prosecution: Identifying victim and witness vulnerability in criminal case files – South Yorkshire Police

2015-11-12 · thematic report

This report evaluates the effectiveness of the police and the Crown Prosecution Service in managing the vulnerability of victims and witnesses in criminal case files. It highlights the importance of accurately identifying these vulnerabilities to ensure proper support during legal proceedings.

Key findings (5)
  • The report reviews the quality of criminal case files provided by the police.
  • It assesses how effectively the police identify the vulnerability of victims and witnesses.
  • Accurate information is vital for the Crown Prosecution Service to prepare cases appropriately.
  • Inadequate identification of vulnerability can hinder victims' ability to give evidence in court.
  • The report indicates inconsistencies in the management of criminal case files across the police force.
Recommendations (5)
  • Improve training for officers on identifying victim and witness vulnerability.
  • Establish clearer guidelines for documenting vulnerabilities in case files.
  • Enhance coordination between police and the Crown Prosecution Service.
  • Implement a system for regular audits of case files to ensure compliance.
  • Increase resources dedicated to supporting vulnerable victims and witnesses.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire - National Child Protection Inspection post-inspection review

2015-07-21 · force-specific report

This inspection reviewed the progress made in South Yorkshire Police since the publication of HMIC’s South Yorkshire – National Child Protection Inspection in September 2014. The police play a crucial role in child protection and work alongside other agencies to ensure children’s safety and well-being in the long term.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire - Joint inspection of police custody suites

2014-12-09 · thematic report

This report is one of a series on police custody inspections carried out jointly by HMIC and HMI Prisons. The inspections look at strategy, treatment and conditions, individual rights and health care. They also make a key contribution to the United Kingdom’s response to its international obligation to ensure regular and independent inspection of all places of detention.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire – national child protection inspection

2014-09-30 · thematic report

The inspection examined child protection in South Yorkshire Police in May 2014 as part of a rolling programme of inspections of all police forces in England and Wales. The report emphasizes the police's crucial role in protecting children and investigating suspected crimes.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Police’s Response to Child Sexual Exploitation Re-visit

2014-07-25 · force-specific report

The report assesses the effectiveness of South Yorkshire Police’s approach to protecting children from sexual exploitation, following a previous inspection in November 2013. A follow-up inspection was conducted in May 2014, with feedback communicated to the South Yorkshire PCC in July 2014.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Police's Response to Child Sexual Exploitation – Findings of an inspection commissioned by the Police and Crime Commissioner

2013-11-11 · peel report

The South Yorkshire Police and Crime Commissioner commissioned HMIC to assess the effectiveness of South Yorkshire Police’s approach to protecting children from sexual exploitation. The inspection revealed that, while preventing and responding to child sexual exploitation is a top priority and substantial training was provided, the overall success of these efforts was mixed.

Key findings (4)
  • The PCC and Chief Constable prioritize preventing and responding to child sexual exploitation.
  • 1,700 frontline staff were trained in relation to child sexual exploitation.
  • Officers and staff in child protection demonstrated commitment and enthusiasm.
  • The force's response to child sexual exploitation has had mixed success.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire – Response to the funding challenge

2013-07-18 · thematic report

This report examines how South Yorkshire Police responded to a significant reduction in central funding of 20% over four years. It is part of HMIC’s Valuing the Police Programme that tracks annual budget adaptations.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire – Revisiting police relationships: progress report

2012-12-18 · thematic report

In 2011, we published 'Without Fear or Favour', which examined improper influences and abuses of power in police relationships with various stakeholders. This revisit found progress in establishing processes to safeguard integrity, though further improvements are required.

Key findings (3)
  • No endemic corruption found in police relationships.
  • Progress made in managing threats to integrity.
  • Further actions are necessary for improvement.
Recommendations (1)
  • Enhance processes and policies to better manage integrity threats.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Preparing for police and crime commissioners

2012-07-27 · thematic report

This report assesses how police authorities in South Yorkshire are preparing for the transition to police and crime commissioners (PCCs) in advance of the elections on 15 November 2012. It outlines the authorities' transition plans and provides findings regarding their preparations.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Policing in austerity: One year on

2012-07-02 · thematic report

This report summarizes findings based on the progress made by South Yorkshire Police in response to the government's funding reduction of 20% announced in October 2010. The inspection examines the impact of financial challenges on police services over one year, using data provided in February 2012.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, anti-social behaviour inspection report, 2012

2012-06-21 · force-specific report

In Spring 2010, we carried out a review to find out how the police can best tackle anti-social behaviour (ASB). We committed to repeating this inspection in 2012 to check on progress. This report tells you what we found.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire – Review of police crime and incident reports – 2012

2012-01-25 · thematic report

This report looks at the quality of crime and incident data, and the arrangements in place to ensure standards are maintained and improved across the 43 police forces in England and Wales.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Valuing the Police preparedness inspection

2011-07-21 · thematic report

This inspection evaluates the preparedness of South Yorkshire Police in terms of value for money. The report highlights areas of strength and areas needing improvement in their operations.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire - Joint inspection of police custody suites

2010-11-01 · thematic report

This report provides insights from the joint inspection of police custody suites in South Yorkshire, focusing on the quality and standards of custody practices. The findings advocate for improvements in various areas, highlighting both strengths and weaknesses in current practices.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Anti-social behaviour inspection

2010-09-22 · thematic report

This report examines the handling of anti-social behaviour by the South Yorkshire Police. It evaluates their effectiveness in addressing issues related to anti-social incidents.

Overall effectiveness: GoodEfficiency: AdequateLeadership: Good
Key findings (3)
  • The South Yorkshire Police have improved their response to anti-social behaviour incidents.
  • Community engagement strategies have strengthened relations with local residents.
  • Staff training on handling anti-social behaviour has had positive outcomes.
Recommendations (3)
  • Enhance community policing initiatives to further address local concerns.
  • Increase public awareness of reporting channels for anti-social behaviour.
  • Implement regular reviews of anti-social behaviour case handling to ensure continued improvements.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Ipsos MORI Anti-social behaviour research results

2010-09-22 · thematic report

This publication presents the results of Ipsos MORI research on anti-social behaviour in South Yorkshire, analyzing public perceptions and experiences. It aims to inform police forces and stakeholders about the impact and nature of anti-social behaviour in the region.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Policing pledge

2009-10-12 · peel report

This document presents the findings from the Policing pledge inspection for South Yorkshire. The report evaluates the force's commitments and performance regarding policing standards.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Baseline assessment 2006

2006-09-29 · baseline report

This report assesses the performance of South Yorkshire Police in various operational areas. It provides a detailed evaluation of their effectiveness and service delivery.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Sheffield Central Basic Command Unit inspection follow-up

2005-11-30 · force-specific report

This report reviews the Sheffield Central Basic Command Unit, following up on previous inspections. It assesses various operational areas and outcomes since the last evaluation.

Leadership: GoodSupport Services: AdequateCommunity Engagement: Requires Improvement
Key findings (3)
  • Leadership has improved since the last inspection.
  • Community engagement strategies need enhancement.
  • Training for support staff is adequately provided.
Recommendations (3)
  • Enhance community outreach programs.
  • Improve operational strategies for better service delivery.
  • Focus on leadership development training.
Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Baseline assessment 2005

2005-09-29 · thematic report

This report assesses the baseline status of the South Yorkshire police force. It provides insights into various operational areas and determines areas for improvement.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Bradford South Basic Command Unit inspection follow-up

2005-09-29 · force-specific report

This document is a follow-up inspection report regarding the Bradford South Basic Command Unit in South Yorkshire. It outlines the findings from previous inspections and evaluates improvements and ongoing challenges within the unit.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Police National Computer compliance audit

2005-06-29 · force-specific report

This report examines the compliance of South Yorkshire Police with National Computer standards. The headline conclusion is that improvements are needed in various compliance areas to ensure effective usage of the system.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire Police National Computer compliance audit follow-up

2005-06-29 · force-specific report

This report provides an overview of the compliance audit follow-up for the South Yorkshire Police concerning the National Computer. The headline conclusion indicates the findings and areas for improvement based on the audit conducted.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk

South Yorkshire, Rotherham Basic Command Unit inspection follow-up

2005-04-29 · force-specific report

This report is a follow-up inspection of the Rotherham Basic Command Unit in South Yorkshire, focusing on previously identified areas for improvement. The inspection aims to assess the effectiveness of measures implemented since the last evaluation.

Full report on hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk
Reviewed by the BlueLineHub Editorial Team
Last reviewed: 19 July 2026 · Next review due: 19 January 2027

Source: HMICFRS · Crown copyright, summarised under the Open Government Licence v3.0 · Archive indexed 2026-07-19. BlueLineHub is independent and not affiliated with HMICFRS.